Oreo-flavored popcorn? Gross, you say. But once you've sunk your teeth into these crunchy, caramely, chocolatey treats (with real bits of Oreos), you'll be addicted. And that's not all—Gary Poppins' intriguing popcorn flavors include cheese jalapeno (appropriately spicy), coffee cinnamon, honey mustard (our personal favorite), cheddar bacon ranch and much, much more. They're all so good, you'll order multiple gift tins—for yourself.

Prices start at $20 per gallon at GaryPoppins.com

NEXT: Olive Foil >>